HomeОбразованиеRelated VideosMore From: UW Video

The Concept of Language (Noam Chomsky)

4264 ratings | 332303 views
Linguist Noam Chomsky, professor at MIT, discusses the ways in which language changes over time and how the idea of a national language is a modern phenomenon. In this University of Washington interview, Upon Reflection host Al Page speaks with Chomsky about how languages are systems of communication rooted in human nature.
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Text Comments (350)
KeskinCookin (2 days ago)
Great insight into language.
Paul Mamani (4 days ago)
Well done
naturphilosophie1 (23 days ago)
the best way to interview chomsky is to get him fired up a bit then get smacked with knowledge.
Jorge Diaz (25 days ago)
I like the "... in fact " he uses mid explanation....its like a "listen up ..you don't wanna miss this"
M Krump (25 days ago)
The first question set the tone... And it's pretty stupid view of point... How german is different from French... ((WTF!!! this question Haha. Le dictionnaire and the Worterbuch are something like 300,000 different words and opposed meaning.))
d Lon (15 days ago)
M Krump Noice. Overstood
M Krump (16 days ago)
+d Lon ... My perspective is based on stuff that I listen. Like any scholarship dudes with doctorats somehow all based on books and some kind analyst from schema(algorithm) that are found through different layers about the same subjects... If you add the others nations perspective... I dont know much I do not have any information about let say Romania or Modern Greece perception.
Cesar Sandoval (25 days ago)
this is still true to date
Murph (1 month ago)
I have read enough of the comments to come to the conclusion everyone must be a liberal-leftist moron. What is wrong with you people? You are obviously incapable of logical thinking. Oh that's right, you're probably also Democrats!
Murph (1 month ago)
Typical! A guy with a degree and tenure and still doesn't know what the hell he's talking about. I am 7 minutes into this video and he could have expressed that France or Italy or any European country, had at one time hundreds of dialects of each of those languages. Small groups or niches of people growing in every facet including language. This is still seen in Asia, more specifically the Chinese and Australia with the Aborigines. You give too much credit to people like Noam Chomsky. Think outside the box people! This goes along with the theory that all humans came from Africa. If everyone came from Africa from the beginning, all language would be the same! My argument Remains the Same... If it can happen in one place, it can happen in an infinite number of places and that goes for everywhere on Earth. It is clear there are different types of humans and as we grew in population those forms of communication I.e., language, developed among the groups. Pseudoscience is really becoming a pain in the ass!
bayan Ibrahim (1 month ago)
The little black thing is it mustache ?
Frank R. Pilot (1 month ago)
One language less wars.
TeaParty1776 (1 month ago)
Chomsky's evasion of man's volitional mind prevents him from understanding language. See Intro To Objectivist Epistemology by Ayn Rand.
Chris Heinrich (1 month ago)
Freggs uh jun filadi mun chura val copa del ihuaniht, voc stalli achumaya. Dil umbroshi fil dusturn. See, I can even invent my own language!
Hugh Laurie & Stephen Fry on language (very funny) -> https://youtu.be/3MWpHQQ-wQg
Nilotpal Mishra (1 month ago)
wise words!
greenspringvalley (2 months ago)
Excellent questions. Asking about humor.
nfltrrr qwsa (2 months ago)
the editing is not awkward enough..
jeff jones (2 months ago)
That is interesting. Every other video, he is talking about politics, psychology, philosophy...You wouldn't know from them, that he is a professor of linguistics! Would have sworn he was a history or political science prof!
bhenadrecra (2 months ago)
that first joke ‘the french would probably say so’ was so obviously cut in afterwards. it’s hilarious
bayan Ibrahim (1 month ago)
bhenadrecra can u explain the joke for me ?
Tim Rowe (2 months ago)
What the fuck, how does he know so much?
Steve C (2 months ago)
At least his hair got more interesting after time...
Tamas Kruppa (2 months ago)
The man is amazing and extremely smart!
Kevin Jones (3 months ago)
This editing is really humorous. The interviewer seems to abruptly and unnaturally interrupt Chomsky with his l'esprit d'escalier to Chomsky’s counter of his question.
Med El (3 months ago)
Makayen ri DARIJA s7ab najib ybano hna
Leo Alexander (3 months ago)
Ahhhh, you fuckin' teachers throwin' shit, "Stop throwin' oranges at us kids. They're hard and ultimately counterproductive!" is what I'd sad ; ) "Why don't you just get right out of town!" Nah, but seriously, we have our fun, but everyone's welcome.
Leo Alexander (3 months ago)
The interviewer's interjections, like that travesty of a joke at 0.37, look edited in; which makes it much worse. That's their idea of a witty comeback.
Sean Healy (3 months ago)
10:09 Dang, didn't know Chomsky grew up on the streets!
Ron Budd (3 months ago)
Sometimes I HATE to listen to this guy but he does know what he's talking about....
Xavier Boyer (3 months ago)
HI All RAS students
ceveretus (3 months ago)
I've never heard Chomsky full of this much doublespeak and contradiction. Of course the frenchman thinks he's speaking the language of truth, Chomsky scoffs. That's his language. And then, showing the same fallacious thinking, Chomsky overlooks the wealth of innovation in English and finds it instead in the stone age tribes of Australia, astounding innovations! Get real. What is he, Jared Diamond? Not a good performance from 'Ol Chompsk here.
Robert Byers (3 months ago)
Why does he accuse americans of KIND of genocide against Indians. tHis is not only false but nobody says it ever who was actually doing history. why does he attack his country? if he hates america then go back to israel and deal with THEIR indians.
Mark Majkowski (4 months ago)
He often answers another question and adds historical distractions. As to learning language versus taught which seems an important distinction — liken learning from what you hear like a child to proper usage to any skill that starts weak and develops. Black dialect was taught for a while in some schools in the 90’s. I think language is like farming. First you eat what you can then you try new options that refine and improve. The way he describes this is that there is no difference between a cave drawing and the LHC or a child’s poem and Hamlet. The language usage seems very different. Science was mostly written in German because the Germans did most of the science. English is international language versus desire for Esperanto. I’d like to know how word distinction and usage develops with technology and specialization — and what he thinks the number of words constitute adequacy for a language. Or how he thinks words cause thought impressions to form or he used. I sense language is how we interact but also how we conceptualize process and distinguish what we experience and humans can distinguish thousands of things in meaningful ways compared to pigs or dolphins or insects. Which might have eat, reproduce, evade as the concepts of language processing they can manage. I’m not a linguist but it seems language is how you compare your thoughts to other’s thoughts or even to think. And the more you can think and express the better. Math is just a language, too, but it seems like it is a bit more precise to describe concepts more complex than rock or on as in no one argues what an = means but sometimes we don’t know what is is. What other species can comprehend an imaginary number or the S wave equation? Probably several in our galaxy (with their own nomenclature and symbols) whom we’ve never met. And I bet we both would quickly agree on what an H atom is or an electron if we don’t kill each other first. But I don’t anything smart enough and powerful enough to get here would find killing us desirable. Because they would have a better concept and language for how to deal with us than we have and I don’t think we’d go a galactic distance to kill unnecessarily.
Mac Barrera (4 months ago)
20:38 - is he describing loss?
osman awad (4 months ago)
Father of language Noman Chomsky.. Thanks for wt given us a huge of informations
Collector Duck (4 months ago)
I wish the interviewer would stop masturbating off the camera. His little moans are incredibly annoying. "uuh.. mmh... umh... uuh.... uh.. mmh... mmh.. mm."
deadsparrow28 (4 months ago)
Chomsky notes around 15:00 that he found himself in places in England where he couldn't understand a word being said. That is also the experience of many English people who travel north or south after a couple of hundred miles.
AnarchoMcTasteeFreeze (4 months ago)
the connections between his linguistic and political thinking come to light
niranjan saikia (4 months ago)
i like his outlook
Noor Mohamed Mohd Yousof (4 months ago)
The Quran speaks about Adam being taught about names of all things and Adam was honored above the angels for knowing these things.
dugfriendly (4 months ago)
What!?! I was a student there in 1989. Ad this to the cool stuff I missed. Like Nirvana playing in the HUB ballroom. Ugh!
Sherif El Kadi (5 months ago)
LOOOOOOOOOL ... Suuuure , of-course Allaho Akbar ! where is Tesla now ? looking for a cap stone ? ??? are you ??
fancynancylucille (5 months ago)
"There are certain principles of human biology which determine what a language can be, and no language can be like that."  What the heck is that supposed to mean?
Fernando MDNA (5 months ago)
I don’t get what he means by the definition of a word is just a hint. A table is a table, right? There are different types of tables, but ultimately they are tables, and you wouldn’t call a chair a table because that’d be wrong!
Fernando MDNA (5 months ago)
In Portuguese you cannot say “I him want to see.” It makes absolute no sense!
Tim Blissett (5 months ago)
Year of 1980 - book title?
Kumari Aarti (5 months ago)
Krpya Hindi me bhi banao.
aarondavid826 (5 months ago)
very knowledgeable in linguistics but terrible in politics, attributing motivations to groups and individuals with absolutely zero logical justifications.
Adrian Glenn Bionat (5 months ago)
damn, Chomsky is gangsta.
Lachlan Byrne (6 months ago)
cunning linguist
Alex Szabó (6 months ago)
26:40 the reporter starts to play on his classic casio watch which we all had in the 90s
recniabsal (6 months ago)
Noam Chomsky could've easily been in the same position as Milo Thatcher in Atlantis. Maybe.... Milo was pretty badass.
Ken W. Simpson (6 months ago)
Chosky claimed 9/11 was not a conspiracy by the Bush administration when obviously it was. Why? Probably because his alma mater, MIT, produced the inept and fake video of planes penetrating and ludicrously passing through the steel and concrete walls of the twin towers - an impossibility. There were no planes, no Islamic terrorists and no Osama Bin Laden. The Israelis set demolition charges weeks earlier to detonate when synchronised with the imaginary aircraft. An Israeli TV crew was on hand to record the catastrophe even before it happened. Chomsky sold out, like the late Christopher Hitchens did over the US invasion of Iraq and 9/11.
TheNameNerd (6 months ago)
I always knew deep down that learning strict rules and grammar was totally pointless, I've never paid any attention to formal grammar and yet I was reading at a college level in 4th grade. I took the ACT without studying and got a 32 in English just by picking the answers that sounded the most fluent and "literary". Obviously it doesn't come naturally to everybody but it's so ridiculous we waste time teaching kids bullshit when you can be a fabulous listener and communicator without it.
Cauasia Rush (6 months ago)
I wanna see where the English language is in 400 years.
Tertiary Adjunct (27 days ago)
It will only spoken by the servants cleaning the floors of the Chinese masters.
Cauasia Rush (6 months ago)
This man is the living embodiment of what a true intellectual is.
Advertising (6 months ago)
"when you're taught rules of you own language in grade school...your actual language nobody teaches you. it grows in your head...you don't learn it anymore than you learn to see..."
Lady Liberty Pictures (6 months ago)
https://www.academia.edu/10739571/I_LANGUAGE_E_LANGUAGE_P_LANGUAGE
Armando Argolvini (6 months ago)
A very rich series of ideas.
Fernando Vazquez (6 months ago)
France is gonna be the language of science!
RationalThinker1859 (7 months ago)
These days we call Chomsky an "armchair" critic. Lot's of commentary, but little research. Good stuff on unpacking grammar though.
marc verhaegen (7 months ago)
Biuological preadaptations to speech & language, google e.g. "Speech originS 2017 Verhaegen"
Lily Jade (7 months ago)
Chinese have that same concept too ... to keep language pure... ha. Taiwanese Mandarin written is different than the newest Mao shorthand Mandarin. Thus China is not pure, to the Taiwanese.
Leisure (7 months ago)
i love how when common assumptions are blown out the water by Chomsky you think yeah this guy makes sense
Taolin Liu (7 months ago)
he talks exactly the same lol
Elon LUSK (7 months ago)
Never graduated... but, I read all about this at the city library, amateur level.
O Smith (7 months ago)
Interviewer: "Will there ever be a time when linguistics not facinate you?" Chomsky "I suppose there will must come some time when your mind deteriorates and you can't deal with hard questions." Apparently that time will NEVER come for Prof. Chomsky!
Randy Jones (7 months ago)
"french follows the order of the thought" what a dumb***
Marcel Bas (8 months ago)
6:09 "...kind of... genocidal".
mike020363 (8 months ago)
The interviewer questions are stunningly lacking in any kind of preparation or direction. Dr Chomsky is game, but I think he’s wondering if he walked into the wrong interview. It’s like having a 30 minute interview with Stephen Hawking and spending the entire time asking him what his favorite foods are and why do they taste the way they do. Jeez.
David Villarreal (8 months ago)
"well, first of all you are assuming that they are different..."
herauthon four (8 months ago)
so, people in the street that do not understand eachother.. close quarters misunderstanding for a long time.. that must have been interesting economics.
AsiA I. (8 months ago)
language came from hindu Indians.
Ahmad Ansari (8 months ago)
Solemn pulses both from brain and heart
KeskinCookin (9 months ago)
Must be hard to interview Chomsky.
d Lon (9 months ago)
Chomsky 1 - education 0
Joseph C (10 months ago)
He is so lovely
rh001YT (10 months ago)
I find Chomsky's theory of universal grammar and language being a mental faculty that will just spring forth as does human growth in general to be very convincing. One thing he get's a bit wrong is his relativist opinion regarding language. He calls some language rules, or most, "artificial". From a deterministic position, nothing is artificial, so by making claims of artificiality he is saying that there is some true state of humans and anything that deviates from that is "artificial" and thus not true and thus bad. Historically however we can easily see a slow march of human cultures towards better quality of this and that and pursuit of ease of living. I suggest this march is driven by those few who with or without force impose new rules on language usage, thus changing the language for the better. Now one might want to say that using the most primitive humans as a ground for establishing authenticity, every change since then is artificial. But from a deterministic perspective, all that has happened had to happen, so how is anything artificial? We should at least be happy that the general trend is towards higher quality and ease of living.
leviathan90 (10 months ago)
The interviewer generally seems to not understand what Prof. Chomsky even means by "language." It seems like he was expecting answers from Strunk & White...
Deganawidah Ayenwatha (10 months ago)
i like the way Chomsky prefaces so many of his comments about the human mind and nature by saying "of which we know very little about". He knows his boundaries of knowledge but more importantly knows the human limitations of conception.
Alastair B (11 months ago)
I like how Noam looks at the structure of the human mind as a starting point.
Jeremy Baker (11 months ago)
I learnt what a pen was (fountain pen) a machine that was a cunt.
Davemac1116 (1 year ago)
Chomsky is a brilliant mind, always sincere, whether in academic or in his political cultural commentaries on elite power and control. He was kind enough to reply to my email on a point regarding scope and limits of human cognition - he replied the same day.
Yodadrinkzoda1 (1 year ago)
I don't agree with his assessment of human nature. I think that animals can have a sense of humor as well, for instance money's and dolphins.
truthscollector (1 year ago)
MR. NOAM CHOMSKY´S SPEECH IS SIMPLY TIMELESS.............. IT SHOULD BE HEARD IN EVERY SCHOOL AROUND THE WORLD.
Soviet Loli (1 year ago)
Take note that this is from 1989.
Soviet Loli (1 year ago)
Which is why the intro and outro are so aesthetic.
Katia (1 year ago)
I would love to hear Chomsky describe his feelings or express any sort of outward joy about what he is clearly passionate about (linguistics and/or politics). I love what he's got to say, but sometimes I wish he would allow a window into his passion or excitement, because these topics certainly make me excited. I want to know why these topics are important to him.
Hughie Spudders (1 year ago)
Wowowow, just listening to Chomsky talk is so inspiring! He speaks so well, with great clarity, and so much knowledge...I feel that I really want to explore language, linguistics, history...and just learn a lot more in general!
Yusra DZtranslator (1 year ago)
I'm Algerian and it really bothers me not being able to understand what Chomsky says.It's as if he was talking to his nose.I find the host's speech much clerer. Is it because of Chomsky's Bostonian accent?
Sebastian Amado (1 year ago)
Noam is always great!
Clockwork (1 year ago)
I like his point at 12:40 about artificial language rules and the politics behind them.
L Hargreaves (1 year ago)
I can never get behind what this guy is saying. You've got to look at him like he's an agent, put there to act as a sort of gatekeeper timestop on linguistic science.
rhn94 (11 months ago)
lol alright conspiritard
JOSE ANTONIO CASTRO (1 year ago)
French is germanic?, oh my god, that ´s stupid!, Chomsky is a Chinese surname just becase i want to said that,
Robinius Arcazius (7 months ago)
French is a romance language with some germanic features. This is what he clearly stated. Remember this language is named after the germanic Franks not the Gauls.
rhn94 (11 months ago)
He never said that retardo.
.
Wow, great interview... props to Al Page.
Satyarth Shankar (1 year ago)
got the man to follow
Gihan Panditha (1 year ago)
cool
Sebastian Amado (1 year ago)
clear as always coming from Noam!!!
sear 35 (1 year ago)
The questions interviewers ask are not of his or her own, interviewers ask questions to feed quizzical minds. Chomski knows that and answered without pause.
zharkoo (1 year ago)
This guy literally never fails to impress
Júlia Vághy (1 year ago)
25:24 "What we call definitions, are not definitions. They are just hints."
A Rem (1 year ago)
23 French people?

Would you like to comment?

Join YouTube for a free account, or sign in if you are already a member.